Christmas is fast approaching, and the holidays are often a time when parents consider getting their child an instrument as a gift. Our guitar instructor Steven Janisse answers five common questions we get from parents about getting a new guitar and looking for lessons for their child.
-
Acoustic? Electric? Classical? Aren’t they all just guitars? And which one should I choose?!
Yes and no! Acoustic, electric, and classical style guitars all have the same basic setup of six strings and at least 12 accessible frets, but differ in the way they each produce sound. Electric guitars have metal strings, the vibrations of which are transmitted into an amplifier via magnetic pickups. Most electric guitars have between 21 and 24 frets, and are optimal for playing in a blues or rock and roll style. Acoustic guitars also have metal strings, but use air vibrating against the instrument’s body to produce their sound. They can have between 12 and 20 accessible frets, and some models have a pickup for amplifiers. Classical guitars are solely acoustic, use nylon strings, and have 12 frets.
Depending on the child’s age, I’ll often recommend an electric guitar, as they are easier for younger children to play and develop their basic motor skills. That being said, there are advantages to acoustic guitars such as portability and developing finger strength. Classical guitars are also a great option, as they are easier on the fingers than acoustic guitars and are ideal for developing good technique. The best way to decide could be just bringing your child to a music store and letting them try out all three styles. Giving them an instrument they’re comfortable with and excited about playing every day is the ultimate goal, so getting their input is probably a good idea.
-
How much should I be spending? Aren’t they going to eventually need a new one?
This can be a tough question to answer, as most families have a budget that they need to stick to and every dollar you can save counts. The instrument is ultimately an investment in your child’s success and the instrument itself.
Children ages nine or younger are most likely going to need a half or three-quarter size guitar to accommodate their finger length, and it is alright to spend a little bit less if your child is going to be learning on a beginner model like this. That being said, there is nothing worse than getting that $40 Walmart guitar-in-a-box option. While attractively inexpensive, these models are often more likely to be a hindrance than a help in your child’s development as a musician. Definitely take the time to do some research, find some reviews, and check to make sure the specific guitar you choose is able to stay in tune and has consistent tone across the neck. Ideally, talk to a musician who can guide you through the process and make sure that your purchase is a worthwhile expenditure.
Older children, especially 12 and up, will need a full-size guitar, and this is where the real price-juggling begins. A decent guitar can be expensive, but is essential for ensuring that your child won’t be held back by any problems with the instrument. It’s just like any other tool: a cheap drill or saw is not going to perform as well or last as long as their more expensive, well-made counterparts. One thing I always recommend is trying to find something used. A $250 brand new guitar probably won’t be amazing, and has very low resale value. The same money can be spent on a used guitar that originally was $450, which you can probably resell for around the same amount that you spent.
-
School is really busy right now–I don’t know if my child has time for lessons. I’ll give them the guitar now and maybe we can start lessons in the summer.
Not really a question, but I hear it all the time. The reality is, if they don’t have the time now, they probably never will. Learning a musical instrument, like anything else, requires a sacrifice of time. Starting lessons while still excited about receiving a new instrument is the best way to get your child into a practicing habit and to get through the difficulty of the first 3 to 6 months. No one just has the time, it’s up to you to make it!
-
I think they want to learn on their own. Do they even need lessons?
The short answer to this is no, they technically don’t “need” lessons IF they’re capable of comprehending musical ideas on their own and have the ability to maintain self-discipline with their practicing. However, most people (adults too!) have difficulty making the time to practice consistently. It’s much easier to stay focused and learn when you have an experienced teacher guiding you through a defined learning track. Lessons are a great way to expose yourself to new ideas and styles, get feedback from a professional who knows your instrument and your capabilities, and strive towards reaching weekly, monthly, or yearly goals. Find an instructor you think your child can develop a rapport with, and don’t be afraid to try a few different teachers before choosing one.
-
Isn’t guitar mostly for boys? Will my daughter even want to play guitar?
NOOOOO!!! This is the worst attitude a parent can have when it comes to the musical future of their child. The idea that one instrument is “more masculine” or “kind of effeminate” is completely wrong. Some of my most talented students have been girls.
While the majority of famous guitar players from the past century are male, there are plenty of women who have proven themselves more than equal to their male colleagues. If you don’t believe me, hop on YouTube and check out some modern players like Ana Vidovic, Orianthi, Kaki King, or St. Vincent. It’s 2014, forget about the stereotypes! There’s no reason that girls shouldn’t be interested in learning guitar, drums, saxophone or anything other instrument they feel passionate about!
– Steven Janisse, InTune Guitar Instructor
Have any other questions about guitars or lessons? Email the InTune studio at intunewindsor@gmail.com.